Get Updates

Race Admissions in US Universities: A Changing Landscape

5 Min Read
November 17, 2023

The topic of race admissions in university applications has long been a contentious issue in the United States, reflecting the broader struggles for equality and civil rights. As high school students navigate the complex world of college applications, understanding the evolving landscape of race-conscious admissions policies is crucial. Let’s get to know the details and current situation of race admissions.

A History of Race-Conscious Admissions

The legacy of segregation and discrimination in the US education system significantly limited access to higher education for minority groups until the mid-20th century. The Civil Rights Movement paved the way for significant changes, including the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which outlawed discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin, including in the realm of education. This act marked the beginning of a new era for race admissions, yet the path toward equal educational opportunities was just beginning.

Introduction of Affirmative Action

In the late 1960s, affirmative action emerged as a set of policies aimed at addressing past injustices and promoting equal opportunities in various sectors, including higher education. Universities began to consider race as one of many factors in admissions processes to foster diversity within their student bodies. This move was both praised and criticized, sparking a debate that continues to this day about the role of race admissions in college admissions.

Legal Standings on Race Admissions

Grutter v. Bollinger (2003): This landmark Supreme Court case highlights the legal battles surrounding race admissions. Barbara Grutter, a white applicant, challenged the University of Michigan Law School's policy of considering race as part of its holistic admissions process. The case underscored the tension between individual rights and the pursuit of a diverse educational environment in the context of race admissions.

By a narrow 5-4 decision, the Supreme Court upheld the University of Michigan's admissions policy. The ruling acknowledged the educational benefits that come from a diverse student body and stated that considering race in admissions, in a limited and carefully tailored manner, was permissible under the Constitution. This decision reaffirmed the legality of affirmative action policies in higher education, albeit under strict scrutiny, marking a significant moment in the history of race admissions.

Potential Impacts of the Ruling on Race Admissions

These discussions on the impact of race admissions policies on minority enrollment, educational diversity, and representation in STEM fields emphasize the interconnectedness of these issues. They underline the critical role that race admissions play in shaping not just the demographic makeup of universities but also the broader societal implications for equity, innovation, and inclusion.

Decline in Minority Enrollment at Selective Universities

A significant consequence of changes in race admissions policies could be the noticeable decline in minority enrollment at selective universities. Historical data post-California's Proposition 209 in 1996 paints a stark picture: Black and Latino student presence at flagship institutions like UCLA and UC Berkeley dramatically dropped, signaling a broader trend that could replicate across the nation. This decline not only affects the individuals and communities directly involved but also the academic and social fabric of universities. Such a shift underscores the importance of race admissions policies in maintaining diverse educational environments.

Reduced Diversity in Higher Education

The potential impacts of racial and ethnic diversity in student bodies due to changes in race admissions poses a threat to the richness of the educational experience for all students. Diversity brings a plethora of perspectives into the classroom, fostering an environment where critical thinking, empathy, and cultural understanding flourish. The diminished presence of minority groups in higher education as a result of alterations in race admissions practices could stifle the exchange of diverse viewpoints, impoverishing the learning experience for everyone involved.

Reduced Diversity in STEM Fields

Further implications of adjusting race admissions policies include the exacerbation of underrepresentation of minority students in STEM fields. Selective universities often lead in STEM education and research; a decline in minority enrollment in these institutions could hinder diversity in these critical areas. This lack of diversity not only impacts the educational pathways and career prospects for minority students but also poses broader implications for innovation and workforce composition in STEM industries. 

Current Landscape About Race Admissions

“Use Diversity in Your Admissions,” Says Joe Biden

In response to the Supreme Court ruling that bars race-specific policies in admissions, U.S. President Joe Biden has taken a stance urging colleges and universities to adapt by considering a broader set of criteria. This push for alternative admissions standards aims to maintain and promote campus diversity in light of the recent legal restrictions. Biden's proposal includes evaluating students' financial backgrounds, geographic origins, educational contexts, and personal experiences with hardship or discrimination, including racial discrimination. 

Alternative Admissions Criteria

The Education Department is set to review existing policies to identify and amend those that may hinder the creation of inclusive student bodies. The push for these criteria comes from evidence that bans on affirmative action in certain states have led to significant drops in enrollment among Black and Hispanic students at top institutions. Biden's advocacy for these alternative criteria underscores a commitment to fostering educational environments that reflect a broad spectrum of American experiences and background. 

Get all the latest updates on U.S. admissions from us! We also offer services to assist your academic journey: 

  1. Maximize your university entrance prep with Admission Mentoring.
  2. Explore your interests and dive into different industries through Passion Project Mentoring.
  3. Improve your grades and knowledge through Academic Tutoring.

Let’s prepare, achieve and flourish together! #itsALLintheprep